Historic Note: Hook Tavern, Capon Bridge, WV

Remains of Hook Tavern, Capon Bridge, WV
(Photo March 4, 2025)

Of all my posts under the rubric of "Alas, Too Late," there is no more tragic an entry than Hook Tavern. The National Register of Historic Places location, lies 150 miles southeast of the house we moved into in April of 2022, just east of the town of Capon Bridge in the New Hampshire County of West Virginia. I would find upon approaching it with my visiting parents in March of 2025 that it had been burned down by arson just six months after our move to the area. Indeed, I quickly realized that I had passed and even stopped to photograph the striking remains on an earlier trip, having no idea what they were. There is no plaque or outward sign of its history on the property.

From the National Register of Historic Places Registration Form I learned the following:

"It is estimated that the rear ell of the inn was constructed first, c.1765. The interior fireplace in this section, between the kitchen and dining area, is constructed massively with large pintle hooks for pots and pans. The end gable chimneys on the main, front section are exterior stone chimneys, suggesting they were constructed before the nineteenth century when brick chimneys grew in popularity (c.1790). Based on their style, the windows and porches appear to date to the 1840s, likely 1848 when Samuel Hook obtained ownership."

Hook Tavern, Capon Bridge, WV
(Pre-fire photo from the Registration Form
for the National Register of Historic Places)

"The inn is located in an area that George Washington originally surveyed between 1749 and 1752."

"While it is difficult to ascertain precisely when each section was built, the exterior trim indicates that it was fully completed by the 1840s. Shortly thereafter, in 1848, the building was conveyed to Samuel Hook and John B. Sherrard. Hook and Sherrard operated the inn as a full service hotel applying for their first license in 1848. In 1862 Hook reapplied alone for a license to operate the inn."

"Hook’s Tavern operated throughout the Civil War and was briefly used as a Confederate hospital for 80 sick soldiers under the command of J.A. Hunter. Severe weather forced Hunter to commandeer Hook’s Inn and his firewood on February 3, 1862."

"Hook’s Tavern was last refurbished in 1956, and closed a few years after that. The tavern remained in the

Hook family and in use until 1987. It has opened for special events occasionally since then."

It was a sad visit indeed.

Est. 1848 - Building constructed: c.1765

Articles: TheClio - National Register - wikipedia - historicnewhampshire

Historical Note: Lee Tuck Lounge, 134 Steuben, Pittsburgh, PA

Former Lee Tuck Lounge
Pittsburgh, PA

In the early evening of Sunday July 20, 1902, the wife and children of well known local politician, hotelier, and saloon keeper Jacob Haule, in crossing the street to their home, somehow fell into the path of an oncoming streetcar and was crushed beneath its wheels. Haule was one of a handful of persons running a saloon in this building in the West End Village neighborhood of Pittsburgh, originally laid out as the dry community of Temperanceville in 1837, before being annexed by the city of Pittsburgh in 1874.

Constructed by Christ Gundlefinger in 1891, the building some 2,000 feet south of the Ohio River has contained a saloon at least as early as 1892, and most of the time from that point to as recently as 2015, although you would never guess that from the ramshackle state of the building today.

Leona Tucker purchased the property in 1977, and ran what would become the longest running and last bar, and perhaps the last residents, to be hosted there during its 120 year history of serving drinks. (Leona passed away in 2003, and I do not know how long she ran the bar herself.) The property is currently for sale. At least in its latter years the bar featured black exotic dancers. It was the scene of another tragic death not long before it closed. On Oct 24, 2014 Ronnell Smith was shot and killed by Lonnie Monk and Anthony Jetter he was leaving the bar.

Christ Gundlefinger sought a liquor license even before his new building was finished, but it's not clear if he got one. In any case by the following year John Kalb ran the building, and with no other licensed house on the street in 1892, began operating a saloon on the main floor. From 1898 to 1910 he would be followed by saloon keepers Jacob Haule Jr., his wife Lena Haule briefly after Jacob passed away, a Mrs. H. Schinneller, and Leopold Von Hedemann. In October 1910 Hedemann transferred the liquor license to Herman J. Theil, whose long run as owner would last through prohibition and into the mid 1940s, and would tragically include the murder of his son John, killed in the bar during an attempted holdup.

After some 35+ years as the "H.J. Theil Cafe" and the "Herman Theil Tavern," the bar would be operated in the 1950s by Marie Schram as the "New Steuben Cafe" or "New Steuben Restaurant and Bar." In the 1970s it would be known as the West End Lounge, before fairly long run as the Lee Tuck Lounge, which it remained for almost 40 years.

Despite - and largely because of - its current state of disrepair, and due to its presence between two large, empty lots along our main route from our home to downtown Pittsburgh, I've probably passed this building a hundred times in the three years we've lived in the area - each time wondering about its history. Catching up with the parts of that history cited here only makes me wonder all the more about its stories from over the years.

Lee Tuck Lounge flier - Sep 15, 2014

134 Steuben St, Pittsburgh, PA 15220

Est. 1977 - Building constructed: 1891

Previous bars in this location: Herman Theil Tavern, New Steuben Cafe, West End Lounge

#6100 - Shooting Star Saloon, Huntsville, UT - 3/9/2025

Shooting Star Saloon, Huntsville, UT

The Shooting Star Saloon, sitting on the Pineview Reservoir in the Wasatch Mountains about 50 miles north of Salt Lake City, is said to be "Utah's oldest business" and "the Oldest Continuously Operating Saloon West of the Mississippi." How exactly they get to the latter claim, with several California bars dating back a few decades earlier, I am not clear about, but I suspect it hinges on the "continuously operated" phrase, alluding to continuous operation through federal prohibition.

In any case, it is quite old, with the building dating back to a mercantile business constructed around 1850, a bar first established here in 1879, and the name "Shooting Star Saloon," along with the current bar space on the main floor, dating from 1940. It is located in the town of Huntsville, population approx. 608. In the 2000 census there were 649 residents, 98.77% white, 0.15% African American, and 0.31% Native American (if you do the math that's one black person and two Indians). To the north are multiple ski resorts, which contributed to the saloon once being listed by USA Today as one of the top après-ski bars in the country.

Shooting Star Saloon, Huntsville, UT

The bar preserves a fine old saloon vibe, with dark wood walls, various old west gear hanging over the bar, taxidermy and skulls, and a large amount of signed dollar bills (once estimated at around 15,000 of them) hanging from the ceiling.

The menu is aggressively simple, listed on the side of napkin dispensers, and comprising one hot dog and six variations of burgers, served with chips. However, the burgers are renowned, once rated 3rd best in the country by USA Today, and I very much enjoyed my cheeseburger, passing on the more famous "Star Burger," which has two beef patties and a layer of knockwurst.

I've added this cozy, historical spot to my highest recommendations list, and close with a few additional notes from a couple online sources:

"The mercantile switched to a saloon in 1879, originally named Hoken’s Hole for its owner Hoken Olsen. Hoken (1862-1945) was the son of Norwegian immigrants who had converted to Mormonism and moved to Utah in 1876 as part of the “gathering.” He became a citizen of the US in 1902. Hunstville’s early newspapers are filled with accounts of how “Slippery Hoken'' had once more been fined for selling liquor without a license, or sent to jail for the same. His wife Maria Bingham operated the saloon when Hoken was in jail."  (Intermountain Histories)

"During the Prohibition Era in the 1920s, alcoholic drinks and card games were enjoyed in secret and a confectionery shop for children was displayed on the top floor of the saloon. However, Hoken continued to be arrested for selling liquor without a license. In 1929, Hoken sold his property to Ben Wood. In 1940, Huntsville’s Carl Stokes moved the saloon upstairs from the basement and named it the Shooting Star."  (ibid) 

"There have been seven owners of the Shooting Star Saloon in the past 135 years. Leslie Sutter is the current owner. Leslie had to prove to the owners she was legit enough to buy the famous saloon by working there for two years. The Shooting Star requires a good steward of the precious historic relics kept inside."

Utah Stories

"Mounted on the wall of the Shooting Star is Buck. He was the largest measured St.Bernard in Guinness Book of World Records. He held this record for seven years. Buck weighed 298 pounds and stood 41 inches tall. He died in 1957, and has been mounted watching over the saloon ever since." (ibid) 

7350 E 200 S, Huntsville, UT 84317 - (801) 745-2002
Est. 1940 as Shooting Star, 1879 as a bar - Building constructed: c1850
Previous bars in this location: Hoken's Hole
Web site: shootingstarsaloon.co - facebook - instagram 
Ranked articles and reviews: intermountainhistories - utahstories - oldestbarineverystate - today's outdoor adventure (video) - postcard.inc - sltrib - deseret - thetvtraveler - onlyinutah - kutv - 10best.usatoday - bearsbutt - highonadventure - yelp - atlasobscura - menu.com - salt lake city weekly - wayneontheroad - tripadvisor 

#6087 - Red Star Inn, Cumberland Township (Fairdale), PA - 2/26/2025

Serb Krewasky, Red Star Inn, Fairdale, PA

Miljo “Serb” Krewasky opened his bar here on Labor Day 1965 -- almost 60 years before I first set foot in it on this day, with him still working the bar. Serb says it had been the Red Star Inn since 1938. In this case, the nickname is accurate, as Miljo ("My-low") is indeed Serbian, and has hosted a Serbian Christmas celebration each Dec 7 for decades. He told me he served in the Army infantry 1961 to '63, and when he heard them call him "Miljo" instead of "Serb," he knew he was in trouble.

There's a framed, yellowed newspaper hanging over the paint peeling from the wall, with a blaring headline: "Cumberland Twp. Plays Wilmerding for Title." "That's older than you are," says Serb, and I thought he was probably wrong, but as it was about the 1952 squads, he was correct. The local Carmichaels boys (Cumberland Township), including freshman Miljo Krewasky, made it all the way to the Western Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic League (WPIAL) B Division Championship that year, having whipped Zelienople 40-14 for their 10th straight win. The "Mighty Mikes" would go on to nip Wilmerding 12-6 to take the title.

Serb was started out as a quarterback and later played linebacker. He is 86 now, but he's not ready to give up the bar. When he does, he says it will be to family only. His hand shakes now as he pours me a shot of Jameson. It was a beer and shot bar when it was full of coal miners, and it's a beer and shot joint today. There's still a framed photo of FDR on the back bar. 

I went from doubting this place was still open to adding it to my list of favorite dive bars in western Pennsylvania. It was an old geezer in an old bar up the road that told me about the place -- "It's even older than this one," he told me. If you're not immediately endeared to a small town working class bar that features a 70-year-old news clip about the local high school team, and with an 86-year-old alumnus pouring you a shot, well, we just have very different tastes.

334 S Vine St, Carmichaels, PA 15320 - (724) 966-9937
Est. 1938 
Articles: greenscenemagazine  

#6088 - Pancake Inn, South Strabane (Pancake), PA - 2/26/2025

Dave Crompton, Pancake Inn, South Strabane, PA

Dave Crompton, AKA "Clem Riley," dressed in a bathrobe and shorts, sat at the bar of in the joint his father bought in in 1964, when Dave was 18. Dave's worked in it ever since, along with his other profession as a bricklayer. It's been the "Pancake Inn" since sometime before that -- I found several liquor license suspensions of former owner Charles Johnson in 1963 and '64, which perhaps contributed to his motivation to sell the place?

You can't get pancakes at the Pancake Inn, nor at any other business in the Pancake, the unincorporated community established in 1822 by settler George Pancake. Before it was a bar, the Pancake Inn building served at least into the 1920s as a one-room schoolhouse, hard by the famous "National Road," originally comprised of the Native Americans' Nemacolin's Trail and Mingo Path, which was later traversed by George Washington himself on his way to erect Fort Necessity during the French and Indian War.

From aged Insulbrick interior it doesn't look like a place where you could take for granted that non-locals were welcomed, but they definitely are by Dave. He tells Dan the bartender that my first drink is on the house, and tries to do the same with my second. He enjoys chatting, generally responding with a satisfied, "Cool beans!"

The decor is just what you'd want in a classic dive -- artifacts that have plainly been collected over many years from many sources, including "Dusty," the mounted deer head, much in winsome disrepair, shabby but perfectly functional.

It's the sort of joint that I will make a point of visiting when I am in the area.

1726 E Maiden St, Washington, PA 15301 - (724) 229-0648
Est. 1963 or earlier 
Previous bars in this location: None known 
Web site: facebook 
Reviews: triblive - untappd 

#6068 - Pleasure Bar, Pittsburgh, PA - 2/7/2025

Pleasure Bar, Pittsburgh, PA 

On our way to a late dinner at Fet-Fisk in Pittsburgh's Bloomfield neighborhood, we stopped in for a beer at the Pleasure Bar. Pleasure Bar is an old neighborhood joint (the sign right out front says since 1941, which isn't exactly accurate but is only a few years off), with a neighborhood bar on the edge of divey-ness up front and an Italian restaurant behind and beside.

If it weren't for our reservation at a difficult to get into restaurant, I would have welcomed the chance to taste the food I smelled there, and could have easily spent a few hours chatting with long-time locals Ollie, Patrick, and 2 others, as well as bartender Christy.

Pleasure Bar, Pittsburgh, PA 

Pleasure Bar was established in 1944 by Samuel and Michel Collinger in 1944 in a space that had briefly been filled by the Friendship Restaurant. It was one of several businesses named "Metropolitan Restaurant" in the 1920s and "Bloomfield Tavern" during the 30s. Pleasure Bar remained in the Collinger family for many years, and all the regulars we chatted with remembered them well.

It seems to have had a colorful history. In the 40s John Collinger was reputed to be one of the biggest numbers operators in the city. The family also didn't seem to buy into the blue laws restricting activities on Sundays, having had their license suspended at least once for serving alcohol on Sundays and another time for allowing dancing (the horror!) on Sundays.

Pleasure Bar has been run by only three families since 1944: The Collinger family eventually sold the business to Robert Mariani and the Mariani family, who ran it for about 25 years until selling it to Jim Campau in 2009, with the Campau family continuing to run it today.

4729 Liberty Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15224 - (412) 682-9603
Est. 1944 
Previous bars in this location: New Metropolitan Restaurant, Bloomfield Tavern, Friendship Restaurant
Web site: pleasurebarpittsburgh.com - facebook - instagram 
Reviews: cooksandeats - yelp - travelocity - thrillist - acrosspittsburgh 

#6064 - Corner Cafe, Pittsburgh, PA - 2/3/2025

Corner Cafe and Bar, Pittsburgh, PA

This is a cool neighborhood bar in the South Side Slopes section of Pittsburgh. It may or may not fit your description of a "dive," it is old school in many ways, but certainly not all, hosting live hardcore bands, comedy acts, and late night drag shows. But for me, the main attraction is the beautiful back bar.

I have nothing like a comprehensive history of the bar, but continue to slowly piece things together. The "Corner Cafe" appears to first show up in city directories in 1938. But the building and hotel have been around since at least the 1880s. A framed photograph in the bar itself claims to be from 1890 and notes that the location was then known as the Fischer Hotel. Sure enough, the 1907 Mowrey Directory for Pittsburgh contains a listing for John Fischer at S 18th and Monestary in the Hotels section -- although I can find no application for a liquor license for the location. (John Fischer does, however, apply for annual liquor licenses for a restaurant at 128 17th Street, which I believe is the location of the current Dish Osteria.) 

Corner Cafe and Bar, Pittsburgh, PA 

I do not know the origins of the bar itself, but it is impressive, with gold trim and appliques, a curve awning-style top section extending outward, and top shelves on either side featuring a small railing. I assume it is pre-prohibition, and if it came from one of the major manufacturers of the time, it seems a little more in the style of B.A. Stevens bars than Brunswick. If anyone can point me to any more history of the building, bar, or business, I'd love to hear it.

  

2500 S 18th St, Pittsburgh, PA 15203 - (412) 488-2995
Est. 1938 or earlier - Building constructed: 1887 or earlier
Previous bars in this location: None known
Web site: instagram 
Reviews: yelp